Them Parks ; Shenzhen, China

This is an exhibition of photographs taken in Shenzhen, China. The work was first exhibited at the Perth Centre for Photography. The following catalogue essay is by Dr Shane Hulbert (RMIT), the catalogue was produced by…

This is an exhibition of photographs taken in Shenzhen, China. The work was first exhibited at the Perth Centre for Photography.

The following catalogue essay is by Dr Shane Hulbert (RMIT), the catalogue was produced by hand on recycled paper and stitched. The catalogue is also available for iPad

Perfect synthetic: Splendid China, Folk Village & Window of the World.

For close to 150 years a photograph’s image began as a latent view of the world, a referent of the moment, concealed until such time that the material was ‘processed’. For a period of time, this latency was the image recorded and the image remembered, a view of a moment in time that only the photographer knew existed, and that, all things being correct, a somewhat faithful reproduction of the location, event, person and/or object would be retained. This image, latent to the world, when eventually revealed, is not quite the same as the memory of that moment in time; its different, it’s a framed version, depicted through the eyes, the experience, the thinking, feeling and interpretation of the photographer who ‘captured’ it. It is, ultimately, a fake.

This is not to suggest that a photograph does not contain some element of truth, it most certainly does, and I’m thinking of academic William Mitchell’s (1944 – 2010) no horse in particular analogy here (Mitchell, 1992, p. 29)

The existence of a horse means that you can take a photograph of some particular horse, but it does not prevent a horse painting from showing no horse in particular. You cannot, however, take a photograph of no horse in particular.

but the idea of a fake in and as photography provides a wonderful point of departure to more fully explore the work of Australian photographer Bronek Kozka. In Perfect:Synthetic, Kozka explores the complex synergy between the real and the fake through an indexical series of images from three theme parks located in the manufacturing city of Shenzhen, on the border of China and Hong Kong Special Administrative Region. Splendid China, Folk Village and Window of the World provide a social and architectural expose of how icons of the world can be condensed and miniaturised into a family-friendly site for leisure.

The Theme Park: Utopia or family-friendly Heterotopia?

The theme park as a site is a profound reflection on culture, history and reality. Something of a utopia, the theme park is a triumph of the contemporary mash-up; everything in one place, a metanarrative for modern life. Each park offering an interpretation of one part of civilisation, either through history, adventure, leisure or fantasy. When I think of theme parks I think of big rides, junk food and slices of a life unknown or made up, played out through characters, architecture and artifice. But are they really ‘utopian’? The word ‘utopia’ comes from the Greek ού (not) and τόπος (place), meaning a place that is not, one that is fictional, not existing, or simply just made up – in others words – a fake. At the same time the homophone ‘eutopia’ from the Greek εύ (good) and τόπος (place) presents an etymological quandary – so combined, as they are in general terms, a utopia is a good not-place. Right. Not quite a museum, the essential theme of the park defines both it’s intentions and it’s cultural, historical and practical positioning.

In the case of Kozka’s images, the theme is the world, or rather a curated version of the world. An entire park dedicated to landmarks and continents, an open air museum where the Eiffel Tower casts a shadow over the Pyramids of Giza, which are seen from a walkway over the Sydney Harbour Bridge, just down the road from the canals of Holland. Time is meaningless – a dinosaur looks out over Mount Rushmore, in much the same way that a young couple having their wedding photographs taken sit in the gardens of 18th century France – you get the idea. Traversed in 20 minutes via a driverless monorail, the park situates the visitor in a miniaturised version of a world full of prosperity and joy, in a place that is both real and fake. The other two parks, Splendid China and Folk Village (combined as one attraction) offer fully miniaturised, 1:15 scale models of China, with a central theme reflecting the nation’s history, culture, art, architecture and customs. In any one day it is therefore possible to visit the Great Wall of China, the Three Gorges Dam, Forbidden City and Terracotta Army. The sites all provide a rich context through which to explore a global experience, condensed into one or two days – but are they really utopian, do they create a sense of good fictional-place. Kozka’s photographs allude to something much more symbolic, yet also more complex than a simple ideal – the cracks appearing in the Mattahorn mountain, or the weathering of the White House, suggest something other than a mini-utopia.

So perhaps utopia is not the right word. Dystopia, or anti-utopia, seems way too negative, and possibly too political (although perhaps appropriate when considering the poorly maintained White House), and characterising theme parks of such grand reflective scale as simply sites or places limits the kind of interpretations suitable to the complexity of the images and the locations themselves.

I am usually reluctant to draw on the wisdom of deceased French philosophers, but in this instance I can’t help but think that Michel Foucault’s use of the term heterotopia is somewhat appropriate here. Foucault uses the term as a way of describing spaces with multiple layers of meaning, or spaces whose relationship to other places is not initially clear. If utopia is a good non-space, and a dystopia an anti-utopia, then a heterotopia is a non-space where things are not as they first seem. Kozka’s theme park images present to us spaces that exist, but are fake, scaled and disassociated from their actual particular space, the locations and representations constructing a juxtaposition of geographically and temporally discontinuous landmarks.

As heterotopian spaces they exist much like the seventeenth-century cabinet of curiosities (although seriously over-sized), the icons and landmarks presented in these images exist, but they are not the ‘real’ version in the sense that they are not where they belong, providing an experience that is only partly grounded. As interpretations of the real, they become mediated through, what human geographer Denis E. Cosgrove calls a ‘… subjective human experience in a way that neither regions nor area immediately suggest’ (Cosgrove 1984, p.13). In this way the sites act as a repository, a collective accumulation of the memories and experiences of the people who visit the park.

This way of seeing is also at the core of how art historian W.J.T Mitchell considers landscape – as a medium, a way of relating culture and place, and a way of understanding the relationship between landscape and the process of forming identity. ‘Landscape is a natural scene mediated by culture. It is both a represented and presented space, both a signifier and a signified, both a frame and what a frame contains, both a real place and its simulacrum (Mitchell 1994, p. 5). Kozka takes this notion of the mediated space and applies a distinct observational juxtaposition between what we think we are seeing and what we know we are seeing. Skyscraper apartments behind the Taj Mahal, palm trees next to the Mattahorn – a disconnection of site and space that creates its own version of curiosity.

Kozka’s photographs provide a clear and emotionally detached insight into the theme park as a heterotopian space. Through serial imagery and photographic convention, he presents a survey of the strange relationship between the real and the fake, the site as visited and the landmark remembered. The use of the formalist traditions of landscape photography is evident in the attention to detail, clarity of focus, the tonal treatment of spatial relationships and the 5x4 aspect ratio.

Images such as The Mattahorn distort the expectation of this formal photography in the way the huge mountain only just manages to sit above the bushes and palm trees. Not quite to scale, yet one of the tallest, and deadliest mountains in the European Alps, the fragility of the cracked and dirty mountain here represents what is so captivating about the work – that how we either remember landmarks, or think we remember them, is disrupted by the very idea that they are part of a theme park. There are several ways Kozka might have shot this mountain, yet by choosing to position it timidly peering out from beneath a manufactured natural environment, suggests a desire to frame it as an other space, one not quite real, but subversively confusing in its presentation.

His attention to size and scale help to reinforce this sense of the other space. In each of the images we assume that our viewing position is the same as the photographers (it usually is), and in this case; front on, standing height and as seen by the tourist. Yet the scale tricks us, some appear as aerial shots, others like we are half way up climbing the Great Wall of China, and others still as though we are impossibly floating mid-air in front of the Taj Mahal, just above the tree line.

Ultimately the success of this work lies in the abstraction of reality – some of the images look like they are photographs of the real thing, some clearly fake, and eventually we start to wonder what is real and what is fake – if this is a theme park, then is not the entire world one big family-friendly heterotopia? If this is fake, then what is authentic?

References

Bruchansky, C (2010) ‘The Heterotopia of Disney World’ in Philosophy Now Issue 77, March 2010

Cosgrove, DE (1984) Social Formation and Symbolic Landscape The University of Wisconsin Press, Madison.

Lord, B (2006) ‘Foucault’s museum: Difference, representation, and genealogy’ in Museum and Society Issue 4(1)

Mitchell WJ (1992) The reconfigured eye: Visual truth in the post-photographic era The MIT Press, Cambridge, Mass.

Mitchell WJT, ed (1994) Landscape and Power, The University of Chicago Press, Chicago.

Salvesen, B & Nordstrom, A (2010) New Topographics 1st edn, Steidl, New York.

Read More

Politics of Violence

To coincide with the launch of this special edition journal; The Politics of Remembering Violence, Communication, Politics & Culture, Vol. 48. I created a exhibition of photography. The exhibition looked at three…

To coincide with the launch of this special edition journal; The Politics of Remembering Violence, Communication, Politics & Culture, Vol. 48. I created a exhibition of photography. The exhibition looked at three separate bodies of work that related to the topic. The exhibition was held at RMIT's Design Hub, September 2015. The following essay is by Prof. Julian Goddard, Head of the School of Art.

When words become unclear, I shall focus with photographs. When images become inadequate, I shall be content with silence. Ansel Adams

Is it possible to make sense of war? Something so horrific but all too real in the lives of millions. Why do we do war? How best to grapple with the understanding of it? The visual record of wars across centuries is strewn with attempts at constructing emotional affect that hope to produce some sort of perspective by which we might approach how to deal with all the complexities and legacies of war. Bronek Kozka’s photographs show us some of the many ways we have tried to picture the emotional memory of war. They are images of images (photographs, dioramas, re-enactments and reconstructed places) designed to produce emotional responses that hopefully give solace and meaning to the tragedy of all wars; images that construct an emotional history of war and its concomitant violence.

Kozka’s photographs document a set of metonyms – images that stand for something far greater their intrinsic reading. The metonymic power of visual images lie in their capacity to move beyond spoken and written language to stand for an emotional experience that is corporal and embodied. Experiences that are hard to fathom and challenge comprehension.

The fabric of the twentieth century includes one of the most unspeakable events of modern culture: The Holocaust (1941-1945) - the industrialised killing of some eleven million individuals, including more than six million Jewish people. By far the most powerful images in this exhibition are those of the remnants of the Auschwitz concentration and extermination camp in Poland, where over one million people were murdered. Kozka’s images, taken at the camp that is now a museum, evoke the unimaginable horror of a history that is almost incomprehensible. These panoramas successfully reconstruct the way in which this place now exists as a memory (nightmare) - a real place that stands as a meta-symbol for atrocity, insanity and Fascism. The metonymic value of this museum is itself hard to comprehend because of what it represents, however if it did not continue to operate with such symbolic force we would be in danger of loosing that memory and put ourselves in even greater danger of repeating what happened at Auschwitz. Indeed these two large panoramas reconstruct the physical experience of visiting the camp through the clever arrangement of various lines of sight that build a set of perspectives that evoke the mad logic of the site.

The pictorial depiction of historical time as a receding perspective is a well-used device in visual culture. Similar to Anselm Kiefer, Kozka’s Auschwitz panoramas use perspective effectively to signal a particularly nasty history. The photographs move us ‘back in time’ through elaborate sightlines pushing our eyes into the background of the images with ever darkening light. The depth of this space is elusive and threatening when understood as a symbol of the atrocious purpose of this space. The variable perspectives in each image also compound the sense of incomprehensibility that confronts us when we try to reconcile the history of this place with its reality. How could such a place be built? How could such an idea have been made real? The answers aren’t easy but they need to be considered.

Similarly the subtle tonal depths of these images compound our experience of the historical tragedy and evil that needs confronting. These dark images are much more than rhetorical as they remind us that the Holocaust was an idea before it was made real. An idea hatched in the dark spaces of the mind of the twentieth century – sinister thinking driven by fanatical ideology which has unfortunate resonance in contemporary twenty first century fundamentalism.

All wars have some sense of warped reasoning but for those left in the wake of such thinking and its consequences the aftermath can be hard to fathom. While the justification for Australia’s involvement in the First World War in Europe and the ‘Middle East’ might still be debated, undoubtedly what Australia is today has in some way been determined by that conflict. Gallipoli (a place) has become a metonym for an idea of Australia (mateship, equality, toughness) and continues to inspire hopes of what Australia might be. Kozka’s photographs of a re-enactment of a charge by Australian soldiers in the Battle of the Nek at Gallipoli (7 August 1915) chronicles the continuing reverence Australians hold for the sacrifices at Gallipoli. That 100 years on people choose to recreate this moment in history is something worth trying to understand. Why create a simulation of this moment? Does re-living (or more precisely re-dying) the historical moment somehow make history real? For those involved in the re-enactment there is surely a feeling of authenticating that moment in history with a view to ensuring ‘they will be remembered’ but the artifice of this simulation can never replace the reality of the horror of the real moment with its the fear and anger and other unknowable emotions experienced by all those men who went to their deaths. The Gallipoli campaign was a disaster in which so many Australians and New Zealanders died for very questionable reasons; yet in the contemporary Australian imagination these men died in the forging of an Australian nation.

How we imagine ourselves is crucial to how we act – but in the case of these simulated images of Australia at war a hundred years ago – it is how we ‘re-act’ that allows us to imagine who we might be. Kozka’s documentation of the re-enactment of the Battle of the Nek, when situated in the context of the other works in this exhibition, reveals another attempt at creating symbolic value based in the memory of war; or more precisely an attempt to create a memory in itself. As the men re-enact the moment they bring a visualisation to an event that could now only be imagined – there is no one still alive who actually experienced it. Even if this imagining is based on an historical record or account – it has to be a simulation that has none of the reality of the desperation of fear and the other emotions driving the real moment one hundred years ago. The recreation is mediated by the very nature of its fabrication. This is the trap of simulation as it can never be the real thing, but always a facsimile. In the re-enactment no one will actually die or be wounded because what Kozka is photographing is a history erased of fear and sanitised for the sake of the demand for contemporary meaning. In a critical sense Kozka’s images reveal the idealisation of this historical moment because of the demand to render it meaningful. The trouble is that by simplifying the Gallipoli campaign to a single image (men leaving the trenches in a charge) – all that was real melts into sentiment that can unfortunately all too easily be turned into nationalist iconography.

Re-enactment, Nurses, Lemnos is full of sentiment, an image captured by Kozka on the sidelines of the re-enactment of the Battle of the Nek. The two nurses are sharing a moment of friendship and solace. The figure on the left possibly consoling the girl on the right who has seemingly received some sort of bad news. The scene evokes the mateship of the women in a time of uncertainty and grief. They rely upon each other. But again this is a simulacrum – not a reality. While the image relays a scene that may well have been played out throughout World War 1, the artifice in the image drains it of any sense of authenticity. The pristine nature of the costumes, the exaggeration of the poses and the shear obviousness of the set-up all suck authenticity from the image. But this is exactly what Kozka manages to capture - an act of artifice, posing as sentiment. Sentimentality, in the way we understand it today, is a relatively new emotion – a feeling that began to be articulated in the Enlightenment as a way of constructing a relationship with memory and history. A way of remembering people and places that were gone or no longer accessible as a result of personal experiences affected by the onset of change synonymous with the beginnings of modernity. Kozka’s image subtlety critiques the manufacture of sentiment as part of the act of recreating history, revealing the way such history is redesigned and manipulated.

Originating in France in the early nineteenth century the first diorama was built by Louis Daguerre (better known as one of the inventors of photography) in 1822. The English use of the word began a year later when the first building for viewing dioramas was constructed to host Daguerre’s spectacle in London. Famous historical battle scenes such as Waterloo, the Battle of Plassey and the Battle of Crecy – all great British victories - quickly became part of the lexicon of images recreated through dioramas on view for an emerging modern English audience. Famous battles and other scenes from history played an important educational role as well as providing curiosity and entertainment. These 3D renditions of history would have been highly contrived with specific goals – not the least constructing British pride and identity. Similarly the wonderful dioramas at the Australia National War Museum in Canberra, depicting significant battles involving Australian troupes, are images that have become part of the Australian psyche.

Kozka’s photographs of the War Museum’s dioramas capture their historical drama emphasising their ability to model ‘how it happened’ and what it might have been like ‘to be there’. Yet as with the recreation of the Battle of the Nek these images are really about how that experience is constructed and the desire to manufacture history and how to render moments that are seminal in the building of national identity and collective self. The three photographs in this set make one consider why is it that images of war are so important in constructing this identity. Should they be lauded and celebrated (some of the dioramas are now treated historical artworks in themselves) or should they be seen for what they are - highly stylised recreations of history, devoid of the real substance of the horror, fear and insanity of war. They are images of industrial violence rendered as spectacle, meant to reinforce questionable notions of nationalism and the validation of war as a necessary part of the maturation of a nation. War and violence are synonymous, yet somehow some wars become part of the narrative of national character and while we can appreciate that history is written by the victorious or ‘winners’, such thinking must be tempered by scepticism if we are not to eulogise violence as a means to and end.

Kozka castes a critical eye over some of the recreations of particular moments from war that carry strong symbolic meaning. In capturing these symbolic recreations he emphasises how such recreations lend themselves to speak about war and violence in a manner that falls so far short of their horrific realities. By isolating and distancing these recreations through the critical power of the lens his images remind us that history is told and constructed through language which can only hope to simulate history but never be it.

Julian Goddard

Head of School, School of Art, RMIT

Communication, Politics & Culture Journal

Read More

"Offshore Processing" Lorne Sculpture Biennale

'Offshore Processing’ is currently showing at the Lorne Sculpture Biennale (Lorne, Victoria). It was made in response to how successive Australian governments, of both sides of the fence have decided to treat some of…

'Offshore Processing’ is currently showing at the Lorne Sculpture Biennale (Lorne, Victoria). It was made in response to how successive Australian governments, of both sides of the fence have decided to treat some of the most at risk and vulnerable people on the planet. From the lies and deceptions with 'children overboard', through to the establishment of 'camps' in other jurisdictions to the manipulation of immigration laws and zones, their behavior and the fact we let them get away with is shameful.

While we may have a government we do not have any leadership. If we can't have leadership anymore, if it's true that the 24 hour news cycle, the obsession with opinion poles and emphasis on re-action rather than action is our reality, then I can only hope our 'governors' (they are NOT leaders) can see the change and 'react'. The death of Syrian toddler Alan Kurdi, the story of baby Asha and the #letthemstay campaign has signaled a shift in the general populous. If policy can't be changed can't for the right reason, by leaders who lead with their heart and heads, then let them do it to score a few percentage points in the latest round of popularity pageants.

Many artists, writers, journalists, musicians and activists have been compelled to act; I speak from my personal experience. By bringing it all to light, by exposing the truths of what's going on, by keeping unrelenting pressure on politicians and with the support of all Australians there will be change.

My sculpture 'Offshore Processing' is a simple floating structure, a facility, cold and austere. It's made from galvanized steel, aluminum and razor wire. For security it has two, mains power independent, high power LED lights and its most important feature: no gate. Once you’re in, it's very hard to get out! Five figures stand rusting (corten steel) behind the fence.

I hope this sculpture will send a message to our politicians, raise awareness and hopefully raise funds* to change our direction as a nation and support the most vulnerable.

*any sales or winnings from this work will go to the Asylum Seeker Resource Centre

Some behind the scenes:

Read More

I recently posted some images of my project for the Lorne Sculpture Bienalle

I recently posted some images of my project for the Lorne Sculpture Bienalle. In that post I mentioned some earlier works that relate to the current project. That started with a piece called 'Dignity' , was created for…

I recently posted some images of my project for the Lorne Sculpture Bienalle. In that post I mentioned some earlier works that relate to the current project. That started with a piece called 'Dignity' , was created for a charity auction to raise money for the asylum seeker recourse centre. I then went on to make two others in that series (they've not been exhibited)

Here is some of that earlier work.

Read More

Offshore Processing

This is a link to some images of the work I have been doing for the Lorne Sculpture Biennale. It is called "Offshore Processing", the album also contains some behind the scenes images and images of the maquette.…

This is a link to some images of the work I have been doing for the Lorne Sculpture Biennale. It is called "Offshore Processing", the album also contains some behind the scenes images and images of the maquette.

https://www.facebook.com/media/set/?set=a.10153692733245862.1073741833.626720861&type=1&l=68c7fffc00

“Offshore Processing” is in many ways a continuation of an earlier series, The Journey, On the Boat and Dignity. The works are my response to Australia’s treatment of asylum seekers and refugees. This work attempts to highlight offshore processing and the treatment of refugees by bringing the issue well within sight, as the work floats offshore. It also attempts to illustrate Australia’s cruel manipulation of the “migration zone” and what is considered to be Australia.

Read More

Building the stage

My most recent series 'Remembering what never happened' is set at party, sometime in the 1980's. Each seen is choreographed to give a hint of what the story might be. While the actors are real, the stage they appear on…

My most recent series 'Remembering what never happened' is set at party, sometime in the 1980's. Each seen is choreographed to give a hint of what the story might be. While the actors are real, the stage they appear on is not. The Californian modernist house was designed by architect Andrew Hayes in specific response to one of the characters - the owner of the property. The design was then 'built' in the virtual world before being photo-realistically rendered for each specific camera angle. The idea of working with this type of virtual world camera me while working on the series 'Perfect:Synthetic' in that series I photographed mannequins embuing them with a sense of the real.

'Remembering what never happened' is until 29 Nov at MARS Gallery. 7 James Street, Windsor

http://marsgallery.com.au/bronek-kozka-remembering-what-never-happened-2015/

Read More

Opening tonight at MARS Gallery

Opening tonight at MARS Gallery 'Remembering what never happened' 6pm 7 James St Windsor An exhibition of photography www.marsgallery.com.au

'Remembering what never happened'
6pm 7 James St Windsor

An exhibition of photography

www.marsgallery.com.au

Read More

'Remembering what never happened' my new exhibition of photography opens 12th…

'Remembering what never happened' my new exhibition of photography opens 12th November, 6:30 at MARS Gallery 7 James Street Windsor (+61 3 9521 7517) The show runs from 7-29 November.

'Remembering what never happened' my new exhibition of photography opens 12th November, 6:30 at MARS Gallery 7 James Street Windsor (+61 3 9521 7517) The show runs from 7-29 November.

Read More